评论来自 5909

This Satchel is on the island of Ranazjar. make sure you pick up the quest "Claim Rackmore's Treasure" (https://www.wowhead.com/classic/quest=6161) and "Book of the Ancients" (https://www.wowhead.com/classic/quest=6027) before going on this quest so you can knock them all out at one time. I killed every Naga between the island and the shore and ONLY dropped once I was on the island.

评论来自 Elise

As you can see how random it is, it dropped for me after 16 kills, on the Ranazjer island. It didnt drop on the road to the island though!

评论来自 Thottbot

At 36,20 I found a "Bubbly Fissure" under the water. If you swim near it, you will gain underwater breathing while you're near it. Very useful if you're not a warlock/shaman/alchemist.

Edit: Apparently I was killing the wrong Naga the whole time, but i'm sure you can other fissures over at the correct location.

评论来自 Thottbot

You don't need water breathing potions, there's a big island that has plenty of tidehunters and sea witches on it. The middle of the island is approximately 29,8 thottbotloc, or 29% from the left of the map and 8% from the top.

评论来自 Thottbot

Ok, read the comment directly above for the location, it really IS the island ! LOL

This is part 2 of the Karnitol quest...

Upon arriving at the island I did this:
(remember, this is just my experience...)

I killed 8 Tidehunters and 2 Sea Witches... it was on the last Tidehunter... also killed 1 Myrmidon, 2 Oracles, 1 Sorcerer, and 1 Deepstrider Giant Elite lvl 38.

Aside from the quest item, the best I got was 2 Naga Scales and 4 Shiny Fish Scales, aside from crap like Fish Oil and small money...

评论来自 Thottbot

There's no trick or tip for this quest ! Just kill the monster's they say on thottbot and the item will drop sometime...

评论来自 Thottbot

Killed 20 odd and finally it dropped from a Sea Witch at 30,12 in the water off the island.

Cheers Thottbot!

评论来自 Thottbot

THis is a very rare drop...as a lvl 37 dwarf paladin i was killing the required guys for literally over 2 hours, damn thing just wouldn't drop. Finally got one off of a Tidehunter...

评论来自 Thottbot

wow it was long but i got the quest item at the same time as my lvl 42! lol

评论来自 Thottbot

Item #1: There are multiple types of naga on the island and around it. However, only two of these five or six types will drop Karnitol's bag.

Item #2: Two of the naga types have a nasty poison. This poison procs every five seconds and lasts for a minute, making it effectively impossible to bandage in between fights.

Item #3: This poison effect stacks. If there is one second left on its timer and you are hit with it again, it resets to 60 seconds. Stacked twice now.

Item #4: There are other naga around the island, but they are deep underwater, and travelling underwater is quite tedious, and the naga here are both spread out and hidden by foliage.

Item #5: Oh, and there's a roving 40 elite giant with an irregular patrol pattern.

This quest blows. If you don't get your drop after about fifteen minutes of solid grinding on the correct nagas, do yourself a favor and let this one go. I grinded four or five bars and quit it in disgust because I was about to level. And I went into this grind in such a good mood, too. Not any more. The poisons and the variety of irrelevant mobs intensifies the aggravating tedium of this drop quest.

And then you have to swim all the way back to shore.

>.<

评论来自 Thottbot

..rising.

!

评论来自 Thottbot

3 hrs.... and still nothing. Why does blizz think grinding like that is fun?

评论来自 Thottbot

Dropped from a Tidehunter on the Island

评论来自 Thottbot

...I got it off my very first Sea Witch. Hurrah for good luck!

评论来自 Thottbot

Focus on the Tidehunters on the island the other posters have mentioned. This yielded quick results for me after endless grinding on the witches.

评论来自 Thottbot

Got it w/in 7 kills. I stuck to the higher levels, and it dropped from a 37.

评论来自 Thottbot

On the Island at 30,7 the first Tidehunter lvl 36 it dropped. It took more time swimming out there.

评论来自 Thottbot

First sea witch I found dropped it.
That sucks to be honest, now I don't got an excuse to grind XP :(

评论来自 Thottbot

Woest Quest ever..! Probaly killed over 500+..Nothing. Not a singel geen or blue item either..But i got about 5g on the big island just for killing all and got to lvl 42 when i begun the quest at lvl 40..

评论来自 Thottbot

got it on the first kill from a sea witch=D... just lucky i guess... the keys took me about 2 hours tho

评论来自 Thottbot

yeaay :) got it from 3rd sea witch.. ;]

评论来自 Thottbot

Wow this one is easy! I got mine on a Sea Witch after the third kill, no problems at all

评论来自 Thottbot

Killed 1 tidehunter, and it dropped on my second sea witch! at aprox 31.7.

评论来自 Thottbot

The island is called Ranazjar Isle. BIG island. not the small one. First kill. got it.

评论来自 Thottbot

top left corner of the map

评论来自 Thottbot

Quest blows ass. Is it really worth it? I went on for about 30 mins and quite frankly, if it takes longer than that of the same repetative $%^& it's not worth it... Might go back later.

评论来自 Thottbot

I got it after i killed 5 tidehunter and 3 sea witch (the sea witch dropped it)

评论来自 Thottbot

I got it on first drop, 35 lvl sea witch!

评论来自 Thottbot

didn't take that long for mine to drop... around 3-4 kills

评论来自 Allakhazam

HAHAHAHA. First try!

评论来自 Allakhazam

just a few min :P the lvl 40 elite showed up and killed me but easy q :P

评论来自 Allakhazam

For some, it is dead on the gold where it will drop off the first mob.

For others, it takes a little bit of work to get it to drop.

Since it only drops off the Sea Witches and Tide Hunters, you might want to kill everything in sight as they randomly respawn as something ( Warrior, Oracle, Razortail, etc. ) else.

I have been battling on the island for a while now, so try not to give up hope on the quest.

As Hielke stated earlier, it does take some time, but wasn't anymore annoying than other quests.

I can assure you of that if you are annoyed at this level... then wait till the 60 quests hit ya.

评论来自 Allakhazam

Perhaps you quested in a wrong area. It did take me some time but wasn't anymore annoying than other quests.

评论来自 Allakhazam

gee...thanks for the great hints Hielke...!

评论来自 Allakhazam

It took me a grand total of 2 minutes to get the satchel, 5 kills and it dropped, doesn't have to be hours and hours of farming. All I did was go to Ranzajar Isle and just kill the Tidehunter and Sea Witch mobs, presto. The 3% drop will also include people killing the mobs without the quest and it can never drop for them thus screwing the %.

Edited, Mon Apr 17 14:39:40 2006

评论来自 Allakhazam

I got the drop on my Hunter in 2 kills, but in 3 hours of atempts on my Priest.

评论来自 Allakhazam

its been 3 hours and im still at this... lol

评论来自 Allakhazam

i think it drops on the same mob always... its a lvl 36 sea witch at 29,8/29,9

评论来自 Allakhazam

dropped on the third kill for me

评论来自 Allakhazam

i was worried after reading the drop rate horrors but after 30-45min. it finally dropped by a sea witch at 30,9. hope this helps and good luck!

评论来自 Allakhazam

You are either extremelly lucky or I`m damn unlucky... Spent almost an hour to get it... I thought it was bugged or something... I was about to quit the quest and go to IF with the heartstone when I realized it was on cooldown, so I just decided to wait 2 min and killed one more mob... guess what dropped...

评论来自 Allakhazam

still farming it... got a whole 1 and a half levels grinding it... kalecgos, alliance
lame
but i got a blue drop>.> fun

Edited, Tue Jun 20 19:58:04 2006

评论来自 Allakhazam

Call me lucky if you wish...got it at the 2º kill

-------------------------

Lvl 42 Holy Priest

评论来自 Allakhazam

Half an Hour it took me :P

评论来自 Allakhazam

It took me 7hrs to get it, and a few hours with another char. - I recommend you skip this quest, waste of time

评论来自 Allakhazam

Heh, 3% droprate :\

I'm gonna do it either way, though, there's nothing wrong with grinding a bit (or a lot)

评论来自 Allakhazam

low drop rate? bull&*!@ always get in 1st try.

评论来自 MaxWilder

I've been grinding about an hour now. I think Blizz might have messed up some of the lower drop rate items, cutting them down to rare drops. Like it should be 10%, but in classic it's maybe 1%. Just a guess. But this has happened more than once now while leveling to my current level of 40.

评论来自 harrygillon

Yeah, this is not 10% don't be deceived.

评论来自 dgbear619

about 2 hrs grinding brutal

评论来自 Oldbury

There aren't too many spawn points. I'd recommend non-Druids to kill them on the isle and kill the other naga present while waiting for spawns. Thanks to the swim speed of aquatic form, the sparse spawns in the ocean are more reasonable to Druids.

评论来自 KrampusJudge

Took me over an hour and around 50+ kills before it finally dropped for me on the island.

评论来自 d3w4yn3

Well... I've killed 60 now, combination of both types that show the potential drop... still no drop, will continue on but just wanted to say that I'll have 40 left to go before I find out if a 1% drop rate is really happening. Spent two hours last night, another hour today to get those 60, with no drop. Hang in there!

评论来自 Prismer

unacceptable drop rate.... i was more than an hour killing these mobss for this

评论来自 out4adance

Got the Satchel From a Sea Witch at 32 18 after searching in the water for about 7 minutes.

评论来自 Mairwyn67

All these years later and the drop rate is still woeful!

评论来自 telia222

MAKE SURE YOU ARE ON THE RIGHT QUEST IN THE CHAIN BEFORE FARMING FOR THIS DROP.

This chain goes:
1. Get assignment from the guy in Nijel's
2. FIND THE CHEST ON THE SHORE
3. Go back to Nigel's and talk to guy
4. GO GET THE SATCHEL FROM THE NAGA

You cannot get the satchel drop until you FIND THE CHEST on the shore first! I think this is the problem, people are not reading the quest carefully and are going on Wowhead, seeing the 3rd quest, and immediately going to the island. Then they don't get the drop for 1-2 hours because you're not on the right quest. It's me. I'm people.

I hope this helps someone else not make my mistake.

评论来自 Nicholaa

As of today, this quest still has garbage drop rates. The 2 mob types that can drop it don't always spawn on the island (even with killing off all the other ones) - and the ones in the water are the same way. Come out here to do The Book of the Ancients quest, but if you kill the ones that are around with no luck, I wouldn't continue to attempt to kill them for too long. Their loot table isn't really worth it.

评论来自 LordVetinari

Just want to share my experience on a Classic Era server - got it on the 8th try, they might've fixed the drop percent to actually be 10 for Classic Era.

Only 2 of the 5 naga types can drop it it seems. Heres the macro I used to target, mark em with purple as its most visible to locate them.
/target slitherblade seawitch
/target slitherblade tidehunter

评论来自 auganator

as of current its still an abhorrent drop rate. took 1hr 25min of nonstop grinding, killed about 120 mobs before i saw it.

评论来自 J11mz

Wow classic era (hc) 2023, second time grinding this in hc both time's 1h+.. writing this while waiting for respawns

评论来自 gildagger

this is easy if you kill the correct 2 mobs. Dropped after 7 or 8 kills. The people saying it took an hour are not reading the quest for the correct mobs to kill, tidehunters and sea witches ONLY drop it.

评论来自 Palayen

I am convinced Classic has introduced a bug for this quest. I farmed the two mobs on the island for over 2 hours, killed over a hundred easily. Got a BoE blue but no satchel. Following the suggestion of another, I went to the 30.9 point. Immediately the sea witch dropped it after the first kill. Blizzard absolutely !@#$ed this one, massively dropping the ball.

3D查看查找升级...链接

小知识

屏幕截图

视频

卡尼托的背包

物品等级：1
任务物品
唯一

卡尼托的背包

相关

贡献